Stepbrother Desire (Erotica)

Alex knew she shouldn’t keep watching the two. But her sister was perched in such a way that she could still look directly into the closet and at Alex. She winked at her then, and Alex blushed, her finger still gently massaging inside her pussy.

Wade scooted Toni towards him, and then leaned in. Alex began to have an orgasm as she saw him slide all the way into her sister. Her own pussy convulsed down on the finger she was pushing inside herself as she whimpered into the rack of clothes she was hiding in. Terrified she was making too much noise, she saw her sister staring directly towards her, a knowing smile on her face as Wade continued to slide in and out of her.

Pleasure flooded every cell in her body and she fell backwards against the wall. She willed herself to fade completely into nothingness, but she began to feel the effects of her orgasm diminish. She quietly crept back through the closet to her own room and crawled into bed, sleep coming quickly for her.

An hour or so later, a soft knock on her door drew her from her nap. “Come in,” she muttered, wiping her eyes.

Toni poked her head in, grinning.

“What?” Alex spat, not in the mood for her crap right then.

She giggled and came in, shutting and locking the door behind her.

“I just wanted to see if you had fun,” she said, smiling widely.

“Last night?” Alex asked. “Yeah, a blast, thanks.” She turned over and faced the wall.

Unaffected by her foul mood, Toni came over and jumped into bed with her.

“I wasn’t talking about last night, but you’re right, we should cover that first. Did you like all the attention?” she asked.

“Do you really not remember what you did?” Alex asked, turning over.

“What I did?” Toni asked, backing up a little as she saw how upset Alex truly was. “I’m not sure I follow. Did we move back to talking about today? Wade wouldn’t have really come in here and fucked you while you were sleeping, Alex.”

“Not today,” Alex clarified. “Last night, on the way home.”

Toni sighed. “No, Alex. I don’t remember anything from the drive home. I remember trying to punch that guy and missing, and then waking up this morning. Why? What awful thing did I do? Did I throw up in the car?” She sounded irritated at being judged by her sister.

Alex sighed and turned back over. “It’s not important.”

“You can’t do that. You can’t be mad at me for something, allude to it, and then not tell me what I did wrong,” Toni said, pulling at her shoulder. Alex had tears in her eyes when she turned back around.

“Sweetie…” Toni said, her tone changing to one of concern.

“It’s fine. If you don’t remember, it’s not important,” Alex said, wiping her eyes.

“Bull shit, it’s not important. What did I do?” Toni asked.

Alex sighed. “I know you were drunk, I just figured you would remember. You got a little friendly on the way home.”

‘Wade brought us home?” she asked.

Alex shook her head. “No Toni, you got a little friendly with me, while I was driving.”

Her face was scrunched up in confusion. “What? I did?”

“Yes, Toni, you did,” Alex said, turning over.

“I’m… I’m sorry,” she replied, the words sounding like a question as she was still clearly not understanding what had happened.

Alex sighed. “Like I said, it’s not important.”

“Alex, just tell me what I did. I’m sorry but I don’t remember anything!” Tony said, growing exasperated.

Alex turned again and looked angrily at her sister. “Well, after yelling to the whole party that I don’t masturbate, which actually sounded more like, “mathermate,” you proceeded to try and demonstrate how on the drive home.”

Toni looked at her flatly for a second. “And that’s what you’re mad at me for?” she asked. “I just made you watch me…”

“You didn’t try to demonstrate on yourself…” Alex said, finally silencing her.

Toni struggled to comprehend for a moment. “I… uh… I’m sorry,” she said, “What exactly did I do?”

Alex sighed. “Do you want a play by play or something? It was inappropriate. I was driving and couldn’t really fight you off.”

Toni swallowed. “So… I touched you?”

Turning, Alex looked over at her, very irritated. “You shoved a finger inside me, only after trying to use your tongue. I was holding your head at bay when you decided to pull my panties away and finger me.”

Toni, shocked, could only shake her head and sit in silence.

Alex turned over and faced away from her. A long minute of silence filled the room. Hearing sniffles, she turned and saw a few tears coming from her sister’s eyes. She sighed and sat up.

“Toni…” she said, her voice softening considerably.

“I’m sorry…” Toni stammered, quietly. “I really didn’t know that happened.”

Alex could see that she was deeply bothered by what she’d apparently done. Her heart breaking, Alex pulled her sister in for a hug. She immediately felt guilty for berating her. Toni was the more fragile of the two. Alex was supposed to protect her and here she was causing her grief. She pulled her down in bed with her, and spooned up behind her.

Toni spun over after a few minutes and began to play with Alex’s long hair.

“If it’s any consolation,” Alex whispered. “You did give me an orgasm.”

Toni looked at her like she’d said she was pregnant. “How is that supposed to make me feel better?” she asked.

“Sorry,” Alex said. “I guess that was dumb.”

“All I need to know is that you’re okay,” Toni said, looking directly into her eyes.

Alex returned the stare and forced a smile. “I’m okay, Toni. I promise.”

That seemed to make her feel better, and she leaned her head down to nuzzle under Alex’s neck. Pulling back a few seconds later, Alex looked down at her. “Can I ask something, though?”

Toni nodded.

She cleared her throat. “Are you bisexual?” she asked.

Toni smirked. “I was hammered, Alessandra,” she said dismissively.

“You were really trying to work your tongue between my thigh and my panties,” Alex told her, looking down at her pointedly.

She sighed and shrugged. “You don’t wonder what it’s like sometimes?” Toni asked.

“What?” Alex asked. “Being with a woman?”

Toni nodded. “Going down on a woman.”

Alex coughed and shook her head. “I uh… no?”

“I mean, it’s got to be different that going down on a man, you know?” she replied.

Alex shifted uncomfortably, which Toni caught.

“You’ve never gone down on a boy, have you?” she asked.

“There’s lots of stuff I haven’t done, Toni. Stop deflecting and answer my question,” she said.

Toni shrugged. “I dunno. I’ve never been with a woman. It’s something I figured I’d try in college. I definitely find women attractive. I mean, I’m obviously attracted to you.”

Alex shook her head. “We’re identical though, I don’t know if it counts.”

Toni was shaking her head in disagreement. “I can look at myself and feel pretty. I can look at you and feel horny.”

Alex blushed and fell silent.

Toni realized what she’d said and grew quiet as well. An awkward silence descended on the two.

“So what did you do today Kenny?” Alex said playfully, breaking the uncomfortable air that had settled on them. “Oh nothing, got fingered by my sister who gets horny just looking at me.”

Toni smirked and then laughed, smacking Alex on the shoulder. “I know for a fact that I must turn you on,” Toni said, eyeing her.Content bel0ngs to Nôvel(D)r/a/ma.Org.

She rolled her eyes. “How’s that?”

“We’re cut from the same cloth. We’ve always been attracted to the same types of boys.”

Alex shrugged. “Sure. I find you attractive,” she said, sarcastically.

Toni sighed. “Would you like me to prove it to you?” she asked.

Sighing, Alex peered at her with a look of doubt.

Toni quickly slid forwards as Alex’s eyes widened. Her soft lips brushed gently across Alex’s. They seemed slightly wet, but were warm and intoxicating. A jolt of pleasure shot through her as Toni’s tongue pushed into her mouth briefly. Alex sighed and closed her eyes as Toni broke the kiss.

A few moments of silence later, Alex opened her eyes and saw Toni smiling at her.

“That wasn’t fair,” Alex said, blushing deeply. Toni giggled. Turning over, she snuggled back up to her sister. “You cheated.”

Toni shrugged, a grin plastered to her face. “So what did you think about today?” she asked, not turning over.

Alex blushed uncontrollably. “I’m… uh…”

“You had to know that Wade and I have been having sex,” Toni said, glancing briefly over her shoulder.

She nodded. “I’ve heard you guys before.”

“So that’s when you masturbate, watching Wade and I?” Toni asked.

Alex shook her head. “No, that was the first time I’ve ever peeked at you two. It was pretty hot and I couldn’t help myself.”

Toni giggled. “Told you that you were attracted to me.”

“Stop it, Toni,” Alex said quietly, still embarrassed. Toni spun over, though, intent on twisting the knife a little deeper.